Why Neville is a perfect fit in the Gryffindor house
J.K. Rowling’s renowned novel, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, depicts
a magical world of Hogwarts, the school of witchcraft and wizardry, where the
story of the protagonist Harry Potter begins. The famed Hogwarts is composed of
four different houses with four distinct features: Gryffindor, Hufflepuff,
Ravenclaw, and Slytherin. In particular, Gryffindor, home of the protagonists,
including Harry Potter, Ron, and Hermione, is “where dwell the brave at heart”,
and “their daring, nerve and chivalry set Gryffindors apart” (92-93). While
many of the critics believe that such characteristics are present in the
protagonists, some wonder if the sorting hat made a mistake with Neville
Longbottom by placing him in Gryffindor. The boy who frequently losses his frog
rarely fits the brave and charismatic characteristics of a Gryffindor in the beginning
of the novel, but Neville sets to prove that the sorting hat was right as he
slowly uncovers his bravery at heart (89).
Neville Longbottom first appears in
the novel as a boy who keeps on losing his pet toad (73). Labelled as the “toadless
boy” thereafter, Neville seems to be a helpless, uncharismatic, and awkward
character (84). The characterization held true even during the sorting hat
process. “The hat took a long time to decide with Neville and when it finally
shouted, ‘Gryffindor’, Neville ran off still wearing it, and had to jog back
amid gales of laughter” (96). After all, he was a boy that “his family thought
he was all- Muggle for ages” (100). At this point, readers may be puzzled as to
why such an awkward boy was chosen as a Gryffindor. Was it because he did not
fit anywhere else? Did the sorting hat give up on the decision?
After the sorting process, Neville
continues to have a hard time proving the readers wrong by struggling in many
aspects at Hogwarts. During potions class, Neville, “who was drenched in the
potion”, “moaned in pain as angry red boils sprang up all over his arms and
legs”, which led Snape to call him an “Idiot boy” (110-111). Later, even
Neville confesses that “he’s not brave enough to be in Gryffindor” as he
refuses to stand up to Malfoy’s bullying (174).
Yet, as the novel progresses, Neville shows
signs of growing up and uncovering the bravery by overcoming his nerves and
flaws. Bravery does not necessarily have to be about being the hero. Neville
shows his bravery through overcoming his flaws: even though Neville was “nervous
and jumpy and frightened” of flying, he took the courage to attempt and succeed
in flying temporarily (although he would break his wrist) (116). Furthermore, he starts showing his bravery
when he stands up for himself after Malfoy’s insult as he declares that he is “worth
twelve of Malfoy” (178). Later, much to everyone’s surprise, Neville “tried to
take on Crabbe and Goyle single-handed” (181). In small increments, Neville
progresses to overcome his fear and growing up as brave and daring Gryffindor.
Finally, as Neville shows his bravery to prevent his friends from not only getting
in trouble, but endangering themselves from further dangers in going after the Sorcerer’s
stone, he is awarded ten points for his house (247). Dumbledore’s recognition
that “it takes a great deal of bravery to stand up to our enemies, but just as
much to stand up for our friends” shows that Neville is a true Gryffindor who
possesses the signatures characteristics of “bravery, daring, nerve, and
chivalry” (92, 247).
Given that there are numerous definitions of brave, I agree with you that Neville depicts bravery throughout the novel. After Harry states that he is not as good of a wizard/witch as Hermione during the potion stage of finding the Sorcerer’s Stone, Hermione responds: “Books! And cleverness! There are more important things - friendship and bravery” (Rowling 287). As you stated, Neville is not the smartest, nor the most coordinated, student at Hogwarts, but what is more important is the friendships he creates and the bravery he shows. I also agree with your statement that Neville slowly becomes more brave. Unlike Harry Potter, Neville is not naturally brave. Harry is someone who is drawn to dangerous or odd situations with a desire to make it right, whereas Neville has to force himself to stand up and be brave. Before declaring to Malfoy that he is “worth twelve of [him]”, Neville refuses to ask for help with dealing with Malfoy because he doesn’t want any more trouble and “choked out” that he knows he isn’t brave enough for Gryffindor (223, 218). Neville needs to be reassured that he is good enough, which gives him the courage he needs to stand up for himself - a sign that he has bravery in him, it just needs to be pulled out of him more than it needs to be pulled out of others.
ReplyDelete